The Difference Between Repairing Cabling and Replacing It

When a tenant reports a network problem, replacing the entire cable isn't always necessary. Sometimes a simple repair restores service; other times replacement is the better long-term solution. Five things property managers should know.

A+ Cable Runners, Commercial Property Management Educational Series: The Difference Between Repairing Cabling and Replacing It. Five things property managers should know: identify the actual problem, when a repair makes sense, when replacement is the better choice, understand the cost difference, and testing helps verify the solution. Not every network problem requires a new cable, and not every damaged cable should be repaired.

This is the fourth post in our five-part Commercial Property Management educational series.

When a tenant reports a network problem, replacing the entire cable isn't always necessary. Sometimes a simple repair can restore service. Other times, replacing the cable is the better long-term solution. Here are five things property managers should know.

1. Identify the actual problem

  • A failed network connection doesn't automatically mean the cable is bad.
  • It could be a damaged jack, a loose termination, a faulty patch cord or a network equipment issue.
  • Testing and inspection help identify the cause before deciding what needs to be replaced.

The cable in the wall is only one part of the connection. A patch cord at the desk, the jack in the wall, the patch panel in the closet and the switch port all sit in the same path. Our post on the cost of a bad network connection walks through the common culprits.

2. When a repair makes sense

A damaged cable may sometimes be repaired using a rated splice or connection method if:

  • The cable is otherwise in good condition.
  • It meets the installation's performance requirements.

Most repairs happen at the ends of the cable: a new jack, a re-terminated patch panel port or a replacement patch cord. A splice in the middle of the run is a different case. TIA-568, the industry standard for commercial cabling, does not permit splices in horizontal copper cabling, the run from the telecom room to the outlet. A splice product rated for the cable's category may restore service, but the spliced run no longer meets that standard, so weigh it as a repair against replacing the run, not as the equal of new cable.

If a repair is proposed, ask what method will be used, where in the run it will be and how the repaired link will be tested afterward.

3. When replacement is the better choice

  • Cables with significant physical damage, water intrusion, crushed sections or other conditions affecting their performance may require replacement.
  • Repeated failures, or cabling that cannot meet the required performance standards, can also point to replacement.
  • So can a need for long-term reliability, when that is a priority.

4. Understand the cost difference

  • A simple termination repair may cost considerably less than installing a new cable.
  • However, repeated repairs, difficult access or an unreliable existing cable can make replacement the more economical long-term choice.

5. Testing helps verify the solution

  • After repairing or replacing network cabling, appropriate testing helps verify that the connection is functioning correctly.
  • Basic wire-map testing and performance certification are different services.
  • The required level of testing depends on the installation and project requirements.

A wire-map test shows the cable is connected correctly. Certification measures it against the performance standard for its category. Our post on cable testing versus certification explains what a PASS does and does not tell you.

Here's what many people don't realize

  • A network connection can stop working because of a small component at either end of the cable.
  • Replacing an entire cable without identifying the actual failure may create unnecessary expenses.
  • On the other hand, repeatedly repairing a cable with underlying damage can waste time and money.

Questions to ask your contractor

  • Has the actual cause of the problem been identified?
  • Can the existing cable be repaired safely and reliably?
  • Is the cable itself damaged, or only its termination?
  • What is the cost difference between repair and replacement?
  • What testing will verify the completed work?

The questions in our earlier post on what to ask before approving a cabling estimate apply to a replacement job too.

The bottom line

Not every network problem requires a new cable, and not every damaged cable should be repaired. The right decision depends on the cable's condition, the cause of the failure, the required performance and the overall cost.

The last post in the series covers how preventive low-voltage inspections can reduce tenant disruptions. To see the cabling work we do, visit our computer network cabling page.

Educational information only. Cabling requirements and performance depend on the installation, equipment, applicable standards and intended application. This is not a substitute for project-specific design or engineering. Always follow applicable codes and manufacturer instructions, and verify project requirements individually.

Common questions

Does a failed network connection mean the cable is bad?

Not automatically. The cause could be a damaged jack, a loose termination, a faulty patch cord or a network equipment issue. Testing and inspection help identify the cause before deciding what needs to be replaced.

When should network cable be replaced instead of repaired?

Cables with significant physical damage, water intrusion, crushed sections or other conditions affecting their performance may require replacement. Repeated failures, cabling that cannot meet the required performance standards, or a need for long-term reliability can also make replacement the better choice.

How do you know a cabling repair worked?

After repairing or replacing network cabling, appropriate testing helps verify that the connection is functioning correctly. Basic wire-map testing and performance certification are different services, and the required level of testing depends on the installation and project requirements.

Related guides